This project by Ivan Brown focused on the design of an improved beehive to support local urban agriculture and was the final project of Ivan’s BTech (BA Hons) in Industrial Design in 2015. From 2016-2017, the project expanded into an MTech (Master’s) in Industrial Design where Ivan expanded the hive into an appropriate technology system for emergent beekeepers. The resultant beekeeping system was refined through field-testing and development towards its implementation and led to Ivan graduating his Masters’ degree Cum Laude. I supervised both projects, with Dr Naudé Malan from the UJ Department of Development Studies co-supervising the Masters. The successful commercialisation of Beegin has become a model for the UJ Department of Industrial Design to help other students see the value of design research to scale ideas developed in their Hons year, into a Master’s, and then into an enterprise.
Overview:
The importance of socially responsible design and participatory research methods for problem-solving in developing nations is unquestionable. The aim of this design research project was to develop a system that can contribute directly and indirectly to food security. In 2015, Ivan began developing appropriate beekeeping technology for local urban farmers as a final BTech Industrial Design mini-dissertation project. The beekeeping technology system that emerged was intended to benefit low-income, small-scale farming communities, as well as promote sustainability in troubled beekeeping and agricultural industries. However, the outcome represented only an initial solution that needed to be field-tested and further developed into a system ready for implementation. It would potentially include additional devices and resources in order to create a system that could be scaled to provide different markets with access to the technology. As such, the MTech research project intended to further develop the appropriate beekeeping technology towards an implementable state through field testing – providing a small group of urban farmers and expert beekeepers with the beekeeping technology and documenting their use of the beehives, production tools and other components over one season (Spring to Winter). Through an iterative Human-Centered Design approach, testing, user participation and design refinement, the appropriateness of the appropriate beekeeping technology was improved and evaluated. The study identified a gap in research on the field testing and development stages of appropriate technology leading to an implementation ready system – an area lacking in academic design research and Industrial Design. Appropriate Technology theories, the Capabilities Approach and Designing for Outcomes were used to create a theoretical framework to position the problem philosophically but also encourage the delivery of tangible benefits through the research. In this way, the study was able to simultaneously address the central problem and affect meaningful change in the lives of the participants.
At the beginning of 2019 Beegin launched as a commercial enterprise. It started as a University project in 2016 with the goal of developing a system for emergent beekeepers to become fully self-sufficient and keep bees in a more sustainable way. Through intensive participatory research and field-testing, Ivan developed an appropriate technology system that is accessible (low-cost & low-tech) and sustainable (economically & environmentally). The system is centred on lightweight-concrete beehives and the moulding tools for producing the hives – appropriating standard Western beekeeping systems. This revolutionary new way of making durable, low-cost, insulating beehives is the answer to so many of the problems faced by beekeepers, and Ivan hopes it will contribute towards a brighter future in bees. The mould sets have currently been sold in 13 countries, with over 3200 Bee Bunka’s produced by Beegin and their customers. This is a story of success both for Ivan as a graduating student immediately becoming a business owner, for the small-scale farmers who have diversified into beekeeping, for the beekeepers who praise the hives for increasing the bees’ productivity, and ultimately, for the bees who seem far happier in their newly designed homes!
For more information please contact Ivan Brown. To see the full range of Beegin’s products visit their website www.beegin.co.za/ and Facebook page www.facebook.com/beeginSA/
Outcomes:
- As of July 2020, 105 mould sets and over 3200 Bee Bunkas have been produced by Beegin and their customers in 13 different countries.
- In 2019, Ivan was awarded an Australian Good Design Award for Design Excellence in Social Impact for his Bee Bunka Moulds.
- Brown, I.L. 2018. An Appropriate Technology System for Emergent Beekeepers: Field testing and Development Towards Implementation. MTech Industrial Design Dissertation. University of Johannesburg. (Awarded Cum Laude). (25Mb).
- Brown, I.L. & Campbell, A.D. 2017. Beehives. Aesthetic Design Registrations A2017/01890 & A2017/01891. (In partnership with UJ TTO)
- Brown, I.L. & Campbell, A.D. 2017. Moulds for Concrete Beehives. Functional Design Registrations F2017/01892 & F2017/01893. (In partnership with UJ TTO)
- Campbell, A.D. & Brown, I.L. 2017. A Potential Difference Model for Educating Critical Citizen Designers: The Case Study of the Beegin Appropriate Beekeeping Technology System. In, Costandius, E. & Botes, H. (Eds.) Educating Citizen Designers in Southern Africa. Stellenbosch: SUNMeDIA.
- Brown, I.L. & Campbell, A.D. 2017. Beegin: Redoing Beekeeping in Southern Africa by Designing for Outcomes. Proceedings of the Cumulus REDO Conference. Kolding, Denmark: Design School Kolding, pp. 169- 178. ISBN: 978-87-93416-15-4.
- Brown, I.L. 2015. An Improved Beehive Design to Support Local Urban Agriculture. BTech Industrial Design Mini-Dissertation. University of Johannesburg. (16Mb).
- Ivan’s Beegin concrete hive featured on Deutsche Welle on the 13 July 2017: http://www.dw.com/en/a-beehive-with-air-conditioning/av-39677845
- Ivan interviewed by Spaghetti.tv for PPC on 11 June 2017. The Beegin beehive was awarded runner-up in Industrial Design category of the PPC Imaginarium Awards in 2015/16:
- Ivan’s presentation for the Design for Social Innovation and Sustainability (DESIS) Annual General Meeting in Hong Kong on 26 November 2016:
- Ivan interviewed about the Beegin beehive on CCTV news 5 November 2016:
- Ivan interviewed about his Beegin beehive for Die Groot Ontbyt on 13 July 2016:
Acknowledgements:
This work is based on research supported in part by the National Research Foundation (NRF) of South Africa for the Thuthuka, unique grant number 88030 held by Angus D. Campbell and titled, Designing Development: An Exploration of Technology Innovation by Small-Scale Urban Farmers in Johannesburg. Any opinion, finding, and conclusion or recommendation expressed in this material are that of the authors, and the NRF does not accept any liability in this regard.